Visioning the Metaverse in Retail and Marketing Communication for 2040 Using 4CF HalnyX

Summary

Client: A research team from the Wrocław University of Economics and Business (funded by the National Science Centre).

Challenge: Exploring 2040 future scenarios for the metaverse’s impact on retail and omnichannel strategies, specifically to identify embedded values and potential trade-offs in metaverse design.

Methodology: Executed a qualitative Real-Time Delphi study via 4CF HalnyX, engaging a panel of 15 foresight experts to dynamically evaluate 21 specific metaverse projections.

Measurable Outcome: Successfully captured 1,064 individual assessments to build four distinct future scenarios (e.g., The Metawars, The Surveillance Metaworld) using advanced clustering methods.

Policy Impact: Revealed a critical neglect of sustainability and civic values in current metaverse trajectories, resulting in a prestigious peer-reviewed publication in Technology in Society.

Client Overview

This project was commissioned by a research team from the Wrocław University of Economics and Business and was funded in its entirety by the National Science Centre (Grant number: 2021/43/B/HS4/01637). The final academic outputs were authored by Monika Hajdas, Joanna Radomska, Aleksandra Szpulak, and Arkadiusz Kawa.

The Challenge

As the metaverse promises to transform digital environments, understanding its long-term impact on retail, omnichannel strategies, and marketing communication is critical. The research team needed to explore future scenarios for the year 2040.

A primary strategic goal was to uncover the “hidden” trade-offs of metaverse value creation by identifying which values are embedded in different future designs. To accomplish this, the project required the engagement of renowned foresight experts capable of addressing both the profound sociological and technological impacts of emerging immersive technologies.

Methodology

The 4CF team collaborated closely with the university’s researchers to formulate and refine the study’s hypotheses. Following a targeted international outreach strategy, 15 highly qualified foresight experts (from a pool of 27 registered candidates) were selected for the panel.

The Process on 4CF HalnyX:

Dynamic Engagement: The study was executed using the 4CF HalnyX platform, utilizing its real-time capabilities to collect dynamic, continuous data from the expert panel.

Evaluation Metrics: Experts evaluated 21 specific metaverse projections, rating each based on its likelihood of occurrence by 2040 and its potential impact on the retail sector.

Data Analysis: The platform allowed experts to assess pairwise correlations between top hypotheses. Consensus was rigorously estimated using the interquartile range and coefficient of variation. The results were then clustered using Czekanowski’s diagraphic method to group related technological and social trends.

Measurable Outcome

The use of 4CF HalnyX ensured rigorous academic data collection, bridging the gap between raw expert intuition and structured scenario generation.

Platform Engagement: The platform successfully captured a high level of continuous engagement, logging a total of 1,064 individual assessments and revisions from the experts over the course of the study.

Scenario Generation: The data clustering initially facilitated three seed scenarios (e.g., “Metaverse Marketplaces”), which were stress-tested with strategic “wild cards.” This ultimately evolved into four distinct, robust future visions: The Metawars, The Meta Business Models, The Great Escape, and The Surveillance Metaworld.

Strategic Insights: The study empirically revealed that current metaverse development trajectories are heavily dominated by market and industrial values, highlighting a critical and systemic neglect of domestic, civic, and green (sustainability) values.

Policy Impact

The rigorous results, trade-off identifications, and scenario analyses generated through the 4CF HalnyX platform were successfully published in the prestigious peer-reviewed journal Technology in Society under the title “The trade-offs of metaverse value creation. Real-Time-Delphi-based scenario analysis by 2040.” This provided the broader academic and business communities with vital, evidence-based foresight regarding the ethical and strategic design of future digital environments.

This research was funded in whole by the National Science Centre, Grant number: 2021/43/ B/HS4/01637.